Talk:穆斯塔法·伊沙克·布塞哈基

Cross-wiki spam

HTinC23 As you can see in ca:Discussió:Mustapha Ishak Boushaki#Currículum, this article is the result of cross-wiki spam that means it is now present on 110 sites throughout Wikimedia. Apologies for writing in English. Paucabot（留言） 2023年11月3日 (五) 18:26 (UTC)

@Paucabot： Hi, thanks for the notification and for fighting cross-wiki spam. Last year I proposed "machine translation" CSD for this article, then an admin reviewed the proposal and sent it to AFD instead. During the discussion it was cleaned up by another editor, and a second admin closed to keep. With the prior proceedings, CSD is unlikely to be approved and it will require a deletion review or an AFD with brand new reason. I would say the page in its current state on zhwiki isn't very problematic. It might as well pass the notability standard on zhwiki (NT:BIO allows "writers who has authority files in multiple, independent authority control catalogues") so I no longer see any simple reason to delete it. ——$\color [rgb]{0.04,0,0.5}{\mathsf {htc_{23}}}$（留言） 2023年11月3日 (五) 19:00 (UTC)

Well, perhaps not notable due to authority control as it usually requires authority file in many national libraries, not ISNI or ORCID. But AAAS fellow might count towards NT:PROF, I'm not sure. ——$\color [rgb]{0.04,0,0.5}{\mathsf {htc_{23}}}$（留言） 2023年11月3日 (五) 19:07 (UTC)

HTinC23 I understand. It does not meet the Catalan Wikipedia standards because there is not a single external source that has significant coverage about this person. All the references are his own articles or pages from his university. All in all, it's a pity that this undoubtfully spam campaign would have nearly achieved its purpose. At least, since I have informed every wiki, it has been deleted from 19 sites. Thanks for your explanations. Paucabot（留言） 2023年11月4日 (六) 07:53 (UTC)